Beauty

CTPA conference: beauty scientists urge context and consistency against misinformation

At the association's first scientific conference in London, industry and government speakers weighed everyday analogies, a single voice, open peer review and listening to undecided consumers.

Dalia MansourOctober 27, 20265 min read10 views

A single droplet falls from a pipette into a wide shallow pool of pale blue water, with a few glass laboratory beakers resting at the edge under soft studio light.

Beauty industry scientists and UK government officials used the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association's (CTPA) first scientific conference to debate how the sector should explain science to consumers at a time of widespread misinformation. The members-only event, held at Central Hall Westminster in London earlier this month, examined how scientific evidence, regulatory decision-making and public understanding can converge.

In opening remarks, Caroline Rainsford, CTPA's director of science, said strong science communication is essential, noting that whatever their role, people in the field spend their days translating complicated scientific information into something audiences can manage.

Putting risk into context

Rainsford, speaking on a panel about building trust through science communication, said placing science in context for consumers is always helpful. She recalled a conversation with salon professionals about an ingredient banned in nail polish, where the context was that a person would have to wear two kilograms of nail polish to get anywhere near the level that causes harm. That kind of framing, she said, really speaks to people.

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, agreed on the importance of context and offered the Olympic swimming pool analogy for communicating liquid relevance: at two litres a day, one pool would take an individual around 4,500 years to drink, so a drop in a pool is not a lot. To fight misinformation, he said, the first step is to explain and give consumers the key to measuring or understanding.

One voice, and its limits

Pissavini tied the issue to education and consistency, saying credibility in science requires consistency and that the sector needs to speak with one voice. He suggested that if dermatologists, doctors and large companies stopped saying ‘I’ and started saying ‘we’, as pharmacy and big groups do, the message would be much stronger.

Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government's Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS), said the idea of a single voice is interesting, but so is the observation that scientists are not very good at it. She noted that the crux of credible science is work that has been critiqued and peer-reviewed, and while she was not suggesting that should stop, the profession could be more cognisant of itself and of how it communicates internally.

Peer review under pressure

Pissavini, who also edits the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said it is crucial that the scientific community keeps the peer review process. The challenge, he said, lies in finding reviewers and in communicating better with audiences both inside and outside the industry. Rainsford added that the industry needs to work collectively to demystify what peer review means, since most people, including industry members, do not understand how the process works; transparency about what it involves will matter going forward.

Meeting people where they are

Claire Coleman, a journalist, editor and consultant specialising in the science behind beauty, said it is important to establish where misinformed conversations are happening, and that correcting misinformation works best by starting where it is. You have to meet people where they are and stand on the same platform, she argued. Middleton agreed that meeting people where they are is critical, adding that consumers government once described as hard to reach are not hard to reach but hard to hear, and that taking more responsibility for listening is key.

Coleman cautioned that the industry will not be able to convert or reach everyone. Its audience should not be hard-liners but the ‘floating voters’ of beauty, meaning consumers who are uncertain and looking to understand better.

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK's Chemical Industries Association, said technical terms and acronyms are best avoided where possible. Messages should be framed from a consumer's perspective, precise and clear without losing the science, which he acknowledged is tricky with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure. Companies can also offer a more balanced scientific perspective: science is not necessarily black and white, and transparency means acknowledging where uncertainties lie, including being upfront about what is actually unknown rather than avoiding awkward questions.

CTPA director-general Emma Meredith closed the discussion by stressing that how the industry communicates science, and that it does so well, is critical.